GO
 
     

HOME > TELEVISION > THE OFFICE (USA)

THE OFFICE (USA)

by Erich Shulte


I know there's a certain reactionary type who will always favor the original or early version of things because it makes them feel more avant garde. Which is kind of a weird combination. A band's first album is always their best album, especially if they hit it big a few years later. You've been following Miike since he was did some slideshow in a basement while you were teaching Engrish in Japan. Audition sucks, and if it must be reviewed, at least the title could be listed in Japanese charachters. Blah, blah, blah. Open a comic book shop.

That's not to say that there isn't a legitimate argument for preferring the UK "Office," all three episodes of it. But there is a better argument for preferring the US version. Apart from Gervais, the US cast is clearly better. Jenna Fishcer and John
Krasinski are becoming stars, and deservedly so. The gradual, bumpy unfolding of their romance is about as good romantic comedy can be. One of the fantasies of love is that you are the only two who really get it. You have finally found someone who understands that you are superior to everyone else. You are the king and queen, surrounded by rooks and pawns. This, among other things, is what Jim and Pam's romance captures so perfectly, especially in contrast to say, Michael and Jan's relationship.



As Michael, Steve Carell's performance has opened the door for him to be a gigantifuck star, putting out like five, crappy films per year. And he too deserves it. The comedy in Michael is nuanced, even when it is obvious. He is a weak man who has fallen into a small position of power that he overestimates. He is always striving to be liked, and thus goes unliked. And his conformity to his misconceptions of what might make people like and respect him has left him oblivious to social convention. Then, finally there are these strands of a real person who values loyalty and cares for those around him. More sucinctly, Michael is a boob who you can laugh at and simultaniously feel sorry for.



Having said all of that, the best character on the show is Dwight, the all purpose, authoritarian supplicant. Part of the brilliance of "Dwight's Speech" is that, although it was lifted from Mussolini, it is an assemblage of all purpose, authoritarian platitudes with no real ideological force. So, naturally it is a home run with a corporate audience. In any authoritarian system Dwight would thrive as a second or third tier official. Yet, he too is sympathetic. His rare moments of success and joy are delightful because he is such a simpleton heel. The product of a beet farming family, whose world view is so informed by action/adventure films that he can be tricked into believing that he is revieving faxes from "future Dwight." I think another reason we can feel for him is that his absurd moralism is at leasted rooted in vague principle, rather than selfishness. He might be an authoritarian, border-line lunatic, but he's no Pat Robertson. And all of this wraps back around because those Faxes are coming from Jim and similar pranks are collaborated with Pam, the king and queen with a combined income of $65,000, toying with their subjects. Without even touching upon the half dozen other great characters and performances that create even more interactions, the elegance of the program should be obvious.

THE OFFICE (USA) Review
One of Ruthless' Best Shows of All-Time
by Erich Shulte
Viewed: 5995 Times
Posted: 6.21.08

Syndicate This Review!
(Help us get the word out...add this article to your favorite news & content aggregators.)
Post to del.icio.us Digg This Post to Furl Post to ma.gnolia.com Post to Newsvine Post to Reddit Post to Spurl Post to Yahoo Post to Facebook Post to Facebook Post to Yahoo



USER FEEDBACK


!!!
Even though The Office sucks balls and anyone who likes it is a flaming homo, there is still the potential for a good review of it, whether positive or negative. This is not a good review (yet) and needs some serious editing.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
!!! on 6/25/2008 @ 8:58:48
Yeah
I just realized that I only come to this site to read the reviewers' complete asshole rantings. There wasn't enough misanthopy in this review. And considering that the last season of The Office had a couple of the darkest episodes ever seen on American television, it seems there's plenty of room to praise it while being an asshole. Liked the dig about "all three episodes" though.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
MBI on 6/30/2008 @ 9:45:34
A little effort next time?
Great show, shitty review. Even without the plethora of typos, this would come across as shallow and pointless.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
phyll on 6/30/2008 @ 11:39:45
Okay, and...?
"I know there's a certain reactionary type who will always favor the original or early version of things because it makes them feel more avant garde." Gee, and I thought this wasn't written by someone in high school. Last time I checked, you can still like the original more and none of it has to do with looking more "avant garde" - which is something only teenagers give two shits about.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
uh-huh... on 7/1/2008 @ 1:50:18
The Office UK
The UK Office series has 14 episodes (including 2 Xmas specials to finish the series). The US version is ok, saw 1st season and aside from the first episode the episodes and stories were totally different.
Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
rossco on 7/1/2008 @ 3:54:08
For God's sake
Somebody copy-edit this!
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Type-O on 7/1/2008 @ 3:49:09
Seriously?
"Has left him in oblivion of social convention"? Come on Erich, there've been better writers on the site but you've still done much better in the past.
Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Czervik on 7/1/2008 @ 7:22:17
Hope you didn't get paid to write this
This is the worst review I ever read on Ruthless. I love The Office but Erich did a lazy half ass job writing this pathetic article. Please, stop writing.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Dwight on 7/2/2008 @ 11:4:05
Whaaat...
I certainly hope that this wasn't as laborious to write as it was to read. Holy shit. Did Erich really write this? Additionally, I don't know why shows like this remain on the air when more superior shows like, say, "Arrested Development" are cancelled outright in their prime.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Patrick on 7/3/2008 @ 1:28:27
Whoa!
I just read the whole thing--God, what an awful review. Did you make those typos on purpose just so you seem laid-back? Anyway, can someone explain what makes this show so great? I find it to be very repetitive, and it paved the way to success for assholes like Rainn Wilson. Jim is probably my least-favorite character on the show; he's just so fucking arrogant. Steve Carell is alright; Get Smart was a pretty good movie, but his work here is just the same ole.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Squirrel on 7/3/2008 @ 5:17:43
Done with this site
Despite the fact that your site is updated about as often as Pauly Shore's resume, I've been checking in regularly because I (mostly) share your opinions. However, favoring the US Office over the UK is an unforgivable sin against good taste. If you prefer lots of episodes to a perfectly crafted story arc, you can get "Friends" on DVD in its entirety for only $99.99.
Rating: 1 out of 5 stars
Pinky on 7/4/2008 @ 4:31:11
I don't hate you.
I think think the readers of this site are simply put off by approval. Your review wasn't bad, it was just not full of the hate and cynicism this site is expected to spew. Prehaps stick to reviewing shitty media and ignore the few things that are worth praise.
Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
Daaz on 7/4/2008 @ 4:36:24
congrats!!
This review is too short and has no point. It's really more of a study of four of the show's characters. However, you didn't fall into the trap of spouting ridiculous, tired anti-nerd shit when you got to Dwight. Congratulations! I'm sure Cale will pick up the slack, although how he does that with a straight face when he had that haircut for more than five minutes I don't know.
Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
alias on 8/31/2008 @ 11:10:06
Wanna leave feedback on this review? Click here!
 
       
         


 

 
  A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M
N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z
 

RUTHLESS T-SHIRTS
You want ‘em, we got ‘em

JOIN THE RUTHLESS FORUM!


"I am free of all prejudices. I hate every one equally." -- W.C. Fields

The Quote Du Jour Archive.